Exploring Task-Level Contingent Mediations for Vocabulary Instruction across Robot, Virtual, and Human Teachers

摘要

Social robots are being introduced in a variety of educational domains with great success. These social robots are often designed by drawing inspiration from practices held by human teachers. Contingent mediations are a prime example of a high-quality teaching practice that supports better outcomes in human-human teaching. This can inform the design of social robots. Current research on robot use in education has focused on curriculum-level contingent mediations where the difficulty level of subsequent tasks are adjusted to the current capabilities of a learner. However, task-level contingent mediations that provide support for students’ learning during a specific task remain unexplored. This research investigates whether patterns of task-level mediations differ between a robot, virtual, and human agent, as well as their effects on learning outcomes. To investigate these research questions, we designed instruction that utilizes contingent mediational flows, based on formative assessment data, to be delivered by a human, robot, and virtual agent to teach grade 3-5 children science words. We identified 23 unique instructional patterns. Then, we compared these patterns across teaching agents and their effects on learning outcomes. Overall, our study demonstrated that high-quality contingent mediations support children’s science vocabulary in learning regardless of the teaching agent.