Fault Prediction in Resistance Spot Welding: A Comparison of Machine Learning Approaches

Abstract

Resistance spot welding is widely adopted in manufacturing and is characterized by high reliability and simple automation in the production line. The detection of defective welds is a difficult task that requires either destructive or expensive and slow non-destructive testing (e.g., ultrasound). The robots performing the welding automatically collect contextual and process-specific data. In this paper, we test whether these data can be used to predict defective welds. To do so, we use a dataset collected in a real industrial plant that describes welding-related data labeled with ultrasonic quality checks. We use these data to develop several pipelines based on shallow and deep learning machine learning algorithms and test the performance of these pipelines in predicting defective welds. Our results show that, despite the development of different pipelines and complex models, the machine-learning-based defect detection algorithms achieve limited performance. Using a qualitative analysis of model predictions, we show that correct predictions are often a consequence of inherent biases and intrinsic limitations in the data. We therefore conclude that the automatically collected data have limitations that hamper fault detection in a running production plant.