Comparing Cytoreductive Nephrectomy with Tumor Thrombectomy Between Open, Laparoscopic, and Robotic Approaches

摘要

Background/Objectives: For surgical candidates with metastatic renal cell carcinoma with a tumor thrombus (mRCC-TT), surgery is cytoreductive nephrectomy with tumor thrombectomy (CN-TT). This is carried out through an open (OCN-TT), laparoscopic (LCN-TT), or robotic (RCN-TT) approach. The purpose of this study was to compare survival outcomes to CN-TT by operative approach. Methods: This was a retrospective analysis of all patients with a diagnosis of mRCC-TT, who underwent CN-TT from a multi-institutional database from 1999–2024. Metastatic locations were qualified as either lung, bone, brain, liver, retroperitoneum, adrenal, paraaortic nodes, or other nodes. Progression was defined as radiographic evidence of recurrence or metastasis not seen on imaging prior to CN-TT. Progression locations were all metastatic locales previously noted plus the nephrectomy bed. Overall survival (OS), cancer-specific survival (CSS), and progression-free survival (PFS) were calculated. Comparisons were performed between OCN-TT, LCN-TT, and RCN-TT. Results: A total of 131 patients were included in the analysis (97 OCN-TT, 25 LCN-TT, and 9 RCN-TT). The TT level was not different (p-value > 0.05) by approach (p-value > 0.05). Preoperative tumor size, final pathologic tumor subtype, and postoperative tumor size were equivalent between the three surgical approaches (p-value > 0.05). Rates of progression were equivalent as were all locations of disease progression in the study (p-value > 0.05). Median OS was 1.6 years in OCN-TT, 1.5 years in LCN-TT, and 2.5 years in RCN-TT (p-value = 0.42). Median CSS was 2.1 years in OCN-TT, 3 years in LCN-TT, and 2.5 years in RCN-TT (p-value = 0.86). PFS was 0.8 years in OCN-TT, 1.2 years in LCN-TT, and 1.2 years in RNC-TT (p-value = 0.76). Conclusions: The operative approach does not affect survival outcomes for CN-TT. Surgeon comfort and patient preference should weigh heavily in operative decision making.